Category: Music

Looking for a Miracle In My Life: The Moody Blues Ask a “Question”

The Moody Blues released “Question” in 1970, created from two songs guitarist Justin Hayward was writing, resulting in a beautiful song suite about seeking solace while struggling with the world’s problems.

Perhaps the most famous instance of songwriters throwing together two unfinished songs to create a great song is when John Lennon and Paul McCartney combined two drafts of songs to create the masterpiece “A Day in the Life” that closed the Beatles’ Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967) album. But not long after that album, The Moody Blues also created a classic song when guitarist Justin Hayward combined two songs he was working on, ultimately forming the song “Question.”

The Moody Blues released “Question” as a single in 1970. And they released a new version of the song in 1989. You might not recall the song from the title, but once you hear it, you will remember it.

The Questions Portion of “Question”

“Question” contains two contrasting parts that might initially seem not to go together. The high-powered first part of the suite provides the title of the song:

Why do we never get an answer when we’re knocking at the door,
With a thousand million questions about hate and death and war?
‘Cause when we stop and look around us, there is nothing that we need,
In a world of persecution that is burning in its greed.

Hayward explained that he was inspired to write this section from Vietnam War protests. While touring in the United States, he heard young people express their concerns about the ongoing Vietnam War.

“I was just expressing my frustration around that, around the problems of anti-war and things that really concerned them, and for their own future that they may be conscripted,” Hayward noted. “How that would morally be a dilemma for them,” he thought, “After a decade of peace and love, it still seemed we hadn’t made a difference in 1970.”

The Love Song Portion of “Question”

After starting with the big questions, the song slows down into an acoustic love song:

I’m looking for someone to change my life;
I’m looking for a miracle in my life;
And if you could see what it’s done to me,
To lose the the love I knew could safely lead me through.

This section stands as a beautiful love song on its own, but it works wonderfully combined with the faster question-asking section.

Why the Two Portions of “Question” Fit Together

Amazingly, the two sections fit together beautifully, despite their origins as different songs. There is nothing inconsistent with being upset and angry about societal problems while also seeking solace in one’s personal life.

But in the grey of the morning,
My mind becomes confused;
Between the dead and the sleeping,
And the road that I must choose.

I’m looking for someone to change my life;
I’m looking for a miracle in my life;
And if you could see what it’s done to me,
To lose the love I knew could safely lead me to
The land that I once knew;
To learn as we grow old the secrets of our souls.

Dick Holler’s song “Sanctuary,” recorded live by Dion in 1971, does something similar by singing in the voice of someone seeing the turmoil of the early 1970s and the failures of the promise of the 1960s. Among those worldly problems, the singer seeks a place of peace with friends.

The Moody Blues song “Question” struck a chord with people in the U.S. and U.K when it was released on the album A Question of Balance (1970). The song became one of the most popular Moody Blues songs, going to number two in the U.K. and number twenty-one in the U.S.

Perhaps because the song is so associated with the sound of The Moody Blues, “Question” is not often covered. But the London Symphony Orchestra recorded an instrumental version in 1978, which inspired The Moody Blues to recruit that orchestra to record a new version of “Question” for their 1989 Greatest Hits album.

The song still sounds great all these years later, while remaining relevant as we try to find love and balance in our lives amidst the confusion stemming from the questions in society about hate and death and war.

As we go into a new year, wishing you peace, love, and the answers to our questions.

And that is the story behind the song. Leave your two cents in the comments.

Buy from Amazon

  • Song of the Day: Dion’s “Sanctuary”
  • Saturday Mornings in the 1960s and 1970s
  • “Hello Christmas” from Dion and Amy Grant
  • Lou Reed Inducting Dion Into Rock Hall
  • Barbara Dane’s Cool Musical Legacy: “Wild Woman,” “Gasser,” “Hard-Hitter”
  • Joan Baez in Concert
    • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    Mahalia Jackson: “Silent Night”

    One of the great and most influential American gospel singers, Mahalia Jackson recorded one of the definitive versions of “Silent Night.”

    One of the reasons I still expand and maintain my own personal CD/MP3 collection is the holiday season, where I want to hear a mix of my favorite Christmas songs I have collected over the years, many that are not on streaming services. Another benefit is that when I put my holiday songs on random play it is more likely one of my favorite recordings will pop up. Of course, a streaming service might make it more likely I would discover something new. But for Christmas, there is a lot to be said for things that are old.

    Amidst my collection on some old gospel Christmas collection CD that you can’t even find referenced on the Internet, I have a beautiful version of Mahalia Jackson singing “Silent Night.” There are many lovely versions of the Christmas classic, but hers has become one of my favorites.

    Jackson, who was born on October 26, 1911 and passed away on January 27, 1972, is one of the most influential American singers. Her gospel recordings are powerful, both because of her voice and because of her genuine faith. So when she sings about the night Jesus was born, you feel you are there with her, capturing the joy and anguish of the world-shaking birth.

    Below, Mahalia Jackson sings “Silent Night,” which was written in 1818 by Franz Xaver Gruber to lyrics by Joseph Mohr in Austria.

    Wishing everyone happy holidays and an inspiring new year.

    Leave your two cents in the comments.

    Buy from Amazon

  • There Will Be Another Christmas
  • We sang, “Silent Night” All Day Long
  • Once Upon a Time in a Far Off Land (Steve Earle’s “Nothing But a Child”)
  • Christmas in Washington: A Song About Heroes
  • “The Little Drummer Boy” on TV and in Song
  • New Holiday Music From Sufjan Stevens: “Silver & Gold”

    • John Lennon and Paul Simon Presenting Grammy for Record of the Year

    In March 1975, John Lennon and Paul Simon appeared together at the 17th Annual Grammy Awards to present an award and to have some fun along with Andy Williams and Art Garfunkel.

    On March 1, 1975, John Lennon and Paul Simon appeared together at the 17th Annual Grammy Awards, presenting the award for Record of the Year for 1974. Olivia Newton-John, who was not present at the awards, would win the Grammy with producer John Farrar for “I Honestly Love You.” But it was the presentation banter between the two legends that seems most significant today. Joined at various points by Andy Williams and Art Garfunkel, the appearances and the jokes seem like a condensed snapshot of 1975 pop culture.

    The four men were connected in a number of ways leading up to this encounter.

    Andy Williams and His Connection to John Lennon

    First, there is Lennon and Simon (perhaps both drunk?) trading jokes with crooner Andy Williams. While Williams may be less known today, if you were around in the 1970s, you knew him. He was well known for his recordings, The Andy Williams Show, “Moon River,” and his Christmas songs and TV specials. He also hosted the Grammy’s that year and in fact every year between 1971 and 1977.

    Viewers would not only know Williams but would know that his former partner “Claudine” referred to in the somewhat risqué banter was his newly ex-wife Claudine Longet. Audience members probably also caught that the “three hits” he referred to from their partnership was their three children.

    Although later in life Williams explained that he was a Republican, he also had been friends with the Kennedys. And he also was outspoken against the Nixon Administration’s efforts in the 1970s to deport John Lennon. So, the affection you see between Lennon and Williams is likely genuine.

    John Lennon in Early 1975

    As for Lennon, in early 1975, he was coming off his famous “Lost Weekend” period and separation from Yoko Ono that lasted from 1973 until early 1975. He was having some success working with other artists (Elton John and David Bowie).

    Also, later in 1975 Lennon would release Rock ‘n’ Roll, his last album before his 1980 return with Double Fantasy. A the time of the Grammy’s, Yoko was pregnant. As later in the year on October 9, 1975, John’s 35th birthday, Yoko Ono gave birth to their son Sean Ono Lennon.

    Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel in 1975

    Simon of course was connected to Art Garfunkel, who appears near the end of the clip. But he also had some mixed experience with Lennon. Simon and Garfunkel had broken up their partnership years earlier. Hence, the joking about whether they would reunite or whether Lennon would reunite (a reference to the 1970’s often-discussed rumors about the Beatles getting back together).

    But in 1975 Simon and Garfunkel were doing some work together, although one might detect some tension in the onstage joking. Apparently, not long before this appearance, Simon and Garfunkel had reconciled to some extent when they visited John Lennon and Harry Nilsson during a recording session in 1974.

    Simon and Lennon’s Relationship

    Apparently, Simon and Lennon had some sort of disagreement during that Harry Nilsson recording session. According to different reports, either Simon walked out or Nilsson threw out both Simon and a drunk Lennon. Lennon also apparently called Simon some names at the time.

    But as you see in the exchange, Lennon and Simon seem to have gotten over that riff. And after John Lennon was killed on December 8, 1980, Simon referenced his sadness about the death in  “The Late Great Johnny Ace,” a song regarding blues singer Johnny Ace who had died in 1954.  “On a cold December evening/ I was walking through the Christmas tide/ When a stranger came up and asked me/ If I’d heard John Lennon had died/ And the two of us/ Went to this bar/ And we stayed to close the place/ And every song we played/ Was for the Late Great Johnny Ace.”

    Before that tragedy, though, back in 1975 for one evening, the four talented artists came together for some fun.

    Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • The Last Simon & Garfunkel Concert
  • Jackson C. Frank’s Beautiful Music From a Tragic Life
  • Sturgill Simpson and the Dap-Kings: “All Around You”
  • This Week in Pop Culture Roundup (Nov. 12, 2011)
  • American Tune
  • American Tune: We Came on a Ship in a Blood Red Moon
    • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)

    Buy from Amazon

    American Tune: We Came on a Ship in a Blood Red Moon

    With only changing a few words in Paul Simon’s “American Tune,” Rhiannon Giddens made the song even more timely.

    In 2022, as part of a Grammy salute to Paul Simon, Rhiannon Giddens joined Simon on stage to sing his song, “American Tune.” Besides the great artist tribute and the wonderful performance by Giddens, a significant aspect of this performance was a change in lyrics that further broadened the meaning of the song.

    When they taught us as kids in the early 1960s about the United States, we may have learned with a less critical eye than what we understand about history today. Still, one thing that always stands out is that the country thrives when it moves forward to become broader, more accepting, and more loving.

    Many of our leaders have understood this truth about our history, perhaps nobody more than Abraham Lincoln, when after a contentious reelection in 1864 during the midst of a Civil War, America did the right thing in choosing the best person for President. He spoke at his inauguration, while the war continued, of having “malice toward none with charity toward all.”

    Simon’s “American Tune” has always connected the conflicting views of America as one of both hope and loss. We’ve previously written in another post about the song and its musical origins by composer Johann Sebastian Bach. We noted there are beautiful covers of “American Tune” by artists like Eva Cassidy and Willie Nelson.

    Giddens’ version makes the song even more relevant for today. As sung by a woman with African-American and Native American ancestry, her moving performance further reminds us of America’s complicated history, while still maintaining the hope for tomorrow.

    The lyric change appears across two lines near the end of the song, a change approved by Simon. In Simon’s original 1973 version, with the nation’s Bicentennial approaching, Simon sang about arriving aboard a certain ship we learned about as kids: “We come on the ship they call The Mayflower/ We come on the ship that sailed the moon.”

    But in Giddens’s retelling, she reminds us that not everyone came on the Mayflower. Importantly, though, the lyrics also remind us that those who did not come on the Mayflower play an essential part of singing our American Tune.

    And high up above my eyes could clearly see,
    The Statue of Liberty,
    Sailing away to sea;
    And I dreamed I was flying.
    We didn’t come here on The Mayflower;
    We came on a ship in a blood red moon;
    We come in the age’s most uncertain hours,
    And sing an American tune.

    Leave your two cents in the comments. Images via YouTube and Wikipedia.

  • Watch Night, Emancipation, and “Mary Don’t You Weep”
  • American Tune
  • John Lennon and Paul Simon Presenting Grammy for Record of the Year
  • The Last Simon & Garfunkel Concert
  • Jackson C. Frank’s Beautiful Music From a Tragic Life
  • Abraham Lincoln The Singer
    • (Some related Chimesfreedom posts.)

    Buy from Amazon

    What Is the Meaning of the Song “Scarlet Ribbons (For Her Hair)”?

    What is the song “Scarlet Ribbons (For Her Hair),” which has been recorded by many artists, really about? While appearing to be a religious song, the message tells us something about parenthood and childhood.

    A number of famous artists have recorded the song “Scarlet Ribbons (For Her Hair).” Although Jo Stafford first had some success with a recording of the song in 1949, one of the most popular versions is Harry Belafonte’s version, first released in 1956. Because of Belafonte’s recording and performances of the song, it has continued on as a classic of sorts, having been covered by Roy Orbison, The Cats, Dinah Shore, Jim Reeves, Gene Vincent, Joan Baez, the Kingston Trio, and in more recent years by artists like Sinéad O’Connor (one of my favorite), Cliff Richard, and Willie Nelson. Perry Como called it “perhaps the most beautiful tune I ever sang.”

    But what is the song about? The song is in the voice of a parent, who is looking in on their daughter at bedtime. The daughter is in prayer and asks “for me some scarlet ribbons,/scarlet ribbons for my hair.” The parent then recounts how all of the stores in town were closed and they could not find any scarlet ribbons for the child that night.

    In the morning, though, the parent again looks into the child’s room and sees in her room, “In gay profusion lying there,/ Lovely ribbons, scarlet ribbons.” The singer ends, amazed at the mystery.

    If I live to be a hundred,
    I will never know from where,
    Came those lovely scarlet ribbons;
    Scarlet ribbons for her hair    .

    On his Stardust album bonus track, Willie Nelson changed the line about living to “a hundred” to “two hundred.”

    Evelyn Danzig wrote the music for the song, and then in 1949, during a party at her home, Jack Segal filled in the lyrics. The song, however, sounds like a timeless folk tale, complete with a mysterious ending that seems fitting of many old folk songs. But what is the song really about?

    The Writing of “Scarlett Ribbons”

    The song’s lyricist, Jack Segal, has explained that he was visiting the home of composer Evelyn Danzig on Long Island, NY and heard her play some music. She played a piano exercise she wrote that intrigued him, sounding to him like a child’s lullaby. Right there, after he was left alone in the room, he sat down and composed the lyrics in fifteen minutes.

    Although the song was soon recorded by several artists, it was not until Belafonte recorded a stripped down version on his second album that the song started to resonate into the classic it has become.

    What is the Meaning Behind “Scarlet Ribbons”?

    The simple explanation behind the song is that it is about a girl’s faith in God being rewarded. Her prayer for the scarlet ribbons is miraculously answered. The proof of the miracle is provided by the parent. The parent had confirmed there was no other way that the little girl could have obtained the ribbons that night, as all of the stores were closed.

    The interpretatin of the song as one about God and faith is consistent with the way many have used the song. For example, after Jim Reeves’ death, his record company included the song on the Jim Reeves gospel collection, A Beautiful Life: Songs of Inspiration (2014) (even though he originally included it on the partly religious album Songs to Warm the Heart (1959)).

    Others have even listed it as a Christmas song.

    While we often should defer to the simplest explanation of something, I think regardless of the songwriter’s intent, there is another reason the haunting song has resonated through the years. The reason is not that people were looking for a song about God providing a girl with ribbons for her hair. At least for me, there is another way that the song has meaning for me. And this interpretation is reflected in the video that Jim Reeves made for the song, where the focus is on the father overlooking his sleeping child. Maybe the song is about parenthood and childhood.

    Like many fathers of a young child, I worry about her constantly. What will life bring for her? What can I do to protect her? How do I make sure she has what she needs and learns what she needs to know?

    So, when I hear “Scarlet Ribbons,” the lyrics provide the viewpoint of the parent. The parent worries that they cannot provide the daughter with the scarlet ribbons she prays for. Wanting to help the daughter find what she wants, and perhaps also to maintain the child’s belief in miracles for a little while longer, the parent searches the town for the ribbons even though it is late.

    So, I relate to the parent’s anxiety. But what about the miracle of the ribbons appearing in the morning? As most parents know, the lives of our children are filled with small miracles every day. Every morning when I wake up, I see my daughter growing in new ways. And each day, she is capable of something new, with or without my help.

    And like the miracle of the ribbons, these little miracles appear and bring me great joy. They also reassure me that something more powerful than me is looking after my daughter, whether that something be what we call “God” or nature or years of evolution or growing up or whatever. And whatever it is called, it is still a miracle.

    One may ask why did the author chose “scarlet ribbons” to reflect the child’s growth? Of course, it could just that Segal in writing lyrics for Danzig’s music found the four-syllable phrase fitted the music. But if the “scarlet ribbons” were selected for a specific meaning, the most obvious one might be that the red ribbons reflect a symbol of a girl growing up and changing, i.e., getting her first period. That of course is not to argue that he song is about menstruation, but such a symbol would tie into one of the ways children change and grow.

    Whether or not the choice of “scarlet ribbons” was made for a reason, the song still seems to be about a parent’s anxiety and faith in a child’s growth. Ribbons may seem silly or insignificant. But in the song they remind us that the little miracles surrounding our children are sometimes more powerful than the parting of the Red Sea.

    Leave your two cents in the comments.

  • When is Mickey Newbury’s “33rd of August”?
  • Roy Orbison Without the Sunglasses: “Only the Lonely”
  • Mary Chapin Carpenter and Emmylou Harris Pay Tribute to Joan Baez
  • Joan Baez in Concert
  • Martin Luther King Jr. on “The Merv Griffin Show”
  • Songs About Homelessness
    • (Some Related Chimesfreedom Posts)